So, you’re ready to ditch the endless parade of plastic bottles and cans and bring the bubble-making magic into your own kitchen. Fantastic choice! But as you start exploring, you quickly run into the big question, the one that keeps aspiring fizz fanatics up at night: Sodastream Vs Aarke Vs Drinkmate. It feels like choosing a side in an epic battle for countertop supremacy. As the voice behind Soda Maker Pro, I’ve spent countless hours with these machines, carbonating everything from plain water to, well, let’s just say some experiments were more successful than others.
Don’t worry, I’m here to cut through the noise. We’re going to break down this clash of the titans, looking at everything from design and functionality to who each machine is really for. By the end of this guide, you’ll know exactly which sparkling water maker deserves a spot in your home.
What Exactly Is a Soda Maker Anyway?
Before we pit our contenders against each other, let’s get on the same page. At its core, a soda maker, or sparkling water maker, is a simple but brilliant device. It injects pressurized carbon dioxide (CO2) from a cylinder directly into cold water, creating the same delightful carbonation you find in store-bought seltzer, club soda, or sparkling water. The process is quick, clean, and gives you complete control over your bubbly beverages.
The Big Fizz: Why You Absolutely Need a Soda Maker
If you’re still on the fence, let me tell you, making the switch is a game-changer. I haven’t looked back since.
- Cost Savings: Think about it. That daily sparkling water habit adds up. Once you have a machine, you’re only paying for CO2 refills and the occasional syrup, which is a fraction of the cost of pre-packaged drinks.
- Eco-Friendly: This is a huge one. You’ll drastically reduce your single-use plastic and aluminum waste. One CO2 cylinder can carbonate up to 60 liters of water, saving hundreds of bottles and cans from landfills and oceans.
- Healthier Choices: You are the master of your drink! You control the sugar, avoid artificial sweeteners, and can create all-natural fruit infusions. It’s the easiest way to make hydration more exciting without the junk.
- Convenience: No more lugging heavy cases of water from the store. Fresh, bubbly water is available on demand, anytime you want it.
|
Our Picks for the Best Soda Maker in 2025
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
|
||
| Num | Product | Action |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | The Carbon8 Pulse Soda Maker Machine, Premium OmniFizz Sparkling Water Maker, Seltzer & More, Soda Stream Machine for Home, Water Carbonator, Fizz Infuser (CO2 Cylinder Not Included), Black |
|
| 2 | Aarke Carbonator lll with CO2 Cylinder, Sparkling & Carbonation Water Machine, Stainless Steel with PET BPA-Free Reusable Bottle Volume 1L/34 fl oz (Matte White) |
|
| 3 | Philips Soda Streaming Machine, Stainless Sparkling Water Maker Easy Install with Quick Twist 1L PET Carbonating Bottle, Soda Maker Compatible with 60L CO2 Carbonator (NOT Included), ADD4902BKOQ/37 |
|
| 4 | Sparkling Water Maker, Soda Streaming Machine with 1L BPA-Free Carbonation Bottle, Makes Home Fizzy Drinks, Seltzer Carbonated Water Maker, Compatible with Standard 60L CO2 Carbonators (Not Included) |
|
| 5 | Aarke Carbonator Pro, Sparkling & Carbonation Water Machine, Stainless Steel with Glass Reusable Bottle Volume 800 mL/27 fl oz (Stainless Steel) |
|
| 6 | Sparkling Water Maker, 1L Soda Siphon, Aluminum Sodastream Soda Makers for Home, Portable Water Maker for Soda Water, Cocktails or Soda Water, Use 8 gram CO2 Cartridges(Not Included) |
|
| 7 | iSi North America Classic Sodamaker Set with Soda Siphon Chargers, 50-Pack - Stainless Steel 1-Quart Sparkling Water System & CO2 Carbonation Chargers for Carbonated Drinks, Juices, Cocktails |
|
| 8 | Portable Sparkling Water Maker - Travel Soda Maker for Home & Outdoor, 1L Carbonating Bottle, 10 pcs CO2 Cylinders, Compact Carbonated Water Machine for Flavored Drinks, Soda Machine (Red) |
|
| 9 | iSi North America Classic Sodamaker, 1 Quart - Stainless Steel Carbonation System for Sparkling Water, Fresh Beverages, Handcrafted Cocktails - Portable & Professional Soda Maker for Restaurant Use |
|
| 10 | SodaStream - Terra Soda Streaming Machine - STARTER KIT - Sparkling Water Maker with CO2 & Bubly Drop - Eco-Friendly, No Batteries Needed - Black |
|
The Main Event: A Head-to-Head SodaStream vs Aarke vs Drinkmate Comparison
Alright, let’s get to the heart of the matter. Each of these brands brings something unique to the table. It’s not about which one is “best” overall, but which one is best for you.
SodaStream: The Household Name
SodaStream is the brand most people think of first. They’ve been around for ages and are essentially the Coca-Cola of the home carbonation world. They offer a wide range of models, from simple manual machines to one-touch electric options.
- Pros:
- Accessibility: You can find SodaStream machines, syrups, and CO2 exchange programs almost everywhere, from big-box stores to supermarkets.
- Variety: They offer a massive selection of models at different price points and a dizzying array of official flavor syrups.
- Ease of Use: Most models are incredibly straightforward, especially their “snap-lock” bottle mechanism. The electric models like the One Touch make carbonation foolproof.
- Cons:
- Plastic Construction: Many of their popular models are primarily made of plastic, which might not feel as premium or durable to some.
- Water Only (Mostly): SodaStream aggressively states you should only carbonate plain water in their machines. Doing otherwise can void the warranty and create a sticky, explosive mess.
Who is it for? The practical family, the beginner, or anyone who values convenience and wide availability above all else. If you just want reliable, no-fuss sparkling water, SodaStream is a rock-solid choice.
Aarke: The Design Icon
If your kitchen is your temple and aesthetics are non-negotiable, you’ve probably already been eyeing the Aarke Carbonator. Hailing from Sweden, Aarke is all about sleek, minimalist design and premium materials.
- Pros:
- Stunning Design: Made from a single piece of stainless steel, the Aarke is a true countertop showpiece. It looks and feels incredibly high-end.
- Durable Build: This machine is built to last. The steel construction gives it a satisfying heft and durability that plastic models lack.
- Simple Mechanics: It’s a purely mechanical device. The lever action is both elegant and satisfying to use.
- Cons:
- Price Tag: You’re paying a premium for that design and build quality. It’s one of the most expensive options on the market.
- Water Only: Like SodaStream, Aarke is designed for carbonating plain water only.
- Slight Learning Curve: The lever system requires a little practice to get your desired carbonation level just right, compared to models with preset buttons.
Who is it for? The style-conscious entertainer, the design aficionado, or anyone who sees their kitchen appliances as part of their home decor. It’s the “form meets function” champion.
Drinkmate: The Infusion Innovator
Drinkmate is the wild card, the creative genius of the group. Their claim to fame is a patented, slow-release fizz infuser cap that allows you to safely carbonate any cold liquid, not just water.
- Pros:
- Unmatched Versatility: This is Drinkmate’s killer feature. Want sparkling white wine? Bubbly apple cider? Fizzy iced tea or juice? You can do it all. This opens up a universe of creative beverage possibilities.
- Great Control: The manual carbonation button allows for precise control over your fizz levels with short bursts.
- Compact Footprint: It’s generally smaller and more lightweight than many competitors, making it great for smaller kitchens.
- Cons:
- More Cleaning Involved: Carbonating sugary or pulpy drinks means you need to be more diligent about cleaning the fizz infuser cap after each use to prevent clogs.
- Mostly Plastic Build: While sturdy, the primary construction is plastic, similar to many SodaStream models, which might not appeal to those seeking a premium feel.
Who is it for? The creative mixologist, the cocktail enthusiast, or any family that wants to make more than just sparkling water (think sparkling juice for the kids!). If you love experimenting, Drinkmate is your undisputed champion.
Quick Comparison Table
| Feature | SodaStream | Aarke | Drinkmate |
|---|---|---|---|
| Best For | Everyday convenience, families | Style, premium feel | Versatility, creativity |
| Can Carbonate | Water only | Water only | Any cold liquid |
| Primary Material | Plastic (most models) | Stainless Steel | Plastic |
| Price Point | Low to Mid-Range | Premium | Mid-Range |
| CO2 System | Screw-in or Quick Connect | Screw-in | Screw-in |
| Operation | Manual or Electric | Manual Lever | Manual Button |
So, Which Soda Maker Is Right For You?
Let’s break it down by lifestyle.
- If you’re the Practical Parent: You need something easy, reliable, and widely available for CO2 swaps. You mostly want sparkling water and maybe some official sodas for the kids. Go with a SodaStream. The Terra or Art models are fantastic starting points.
- If you’re the Style-Conscious Host: Your kitchen looks like it’s straight out of a magazine. You want an appliance that doubles as a statement piece and you primarily drink sparkling water or simple cocktails like a vodka soda. The Aarke Carbonator is calling your name.
- If you’re the Creative Mixologist: You see a bottle of chilled white wine and think, “This would be better with bubbles.” You love making custom cocktails and non-alcoholic creations and aren’t afraid of a little extra cleanup. You need a Drinkmate. Its ability to carbonate anything is a game-changer you won’t want to live without.
Getting Started: Your First Fizz
Once you’ve chosen your champion, using it is a breeze.
- Chill Your Water: This is the golden rule. Cold water holds carbonation significantly better than room-temperature water. I keep a bottle or two of filtered water in the fridge at all times, ready for fizzing.
- Fill the Bottle: Fill your carbonating bottle to the designated fill line. Don’t overfill!
- Attach the Bottle: Secure the bottle to the machine. This will be a screw-in or a snap-lock mechanism depending on your model.
- Carbonate: Press the button or pull the lever. Most manuals recommend 3-5 short presses for standard fizz, and more for an extra-bubbly result. You’ll hear a “buzz” or “hiss” with each press.
- Release and Enjoy: Tilt the bottle and release it from the machine. You can now add your favorite flavors or enjoy it plain.
Pro Tips for Next-Level Fizz
As someone who uses their machine daily, I’ve picked up a few tricks.
“The single biggest mistake new users make is not using cold enough water,” notes beverage specialist James Hoffman. “Chilling your water to near-freezing temperatures before carbonating will give you a crisper, more intense, and longer-lasting fizz every single time. It’s basic chemistry, but it makes all the difference.”
- Add Flavor After Carbonating: Unless you’re using a Drinkmate for a pre-mixed beverage, always add your syrups and flavorings after you’ve carbonated the plain water. Adding them before will cause a foamy mess and can damage your machine.
- Chill Your Syrups: Adding cold syrup to cold, fizzy water helps maintain the maximum level of carbonation.
- Think Beyond Syrups: Muddle some fresh mint and lime in your glass before pouring in your sparkling water. Add a splash of bitters or a squeeze of fresh grapefruit. The possibilities are endless. Check out [our guide to creative soda maker recipes]() for more inspiration.
A Final Word on the Great Soda Maker Debate
In the SodaStream vs Aarke vs Drinkmate battle, there’s no single loser—only a winner for your specific needs. SodaStream brings unmatched convenience and accessibility. Aarke delivers unparalleled design and a premium user experience. And Drinkmate unleashes a world of creative potential, letting you carbonate literally any cold drink you can dream up.
By thinking about how you’ll really use your machine, you can confidently choose the perfect partner for your sparkling beverage journey. Whichever you pick, welcome to the club! You’re about to save money, help the planet, and enjoy the best-tasting bubbly drinks of your life, right from your own kitchen.